Skip to Content

How to Deal With Your Toddler’s Tantrums Without Using Time-Outs and Punishments

How to Deal With Your Toddler’s Tantrums Without Using Time-Outs and Punishments

Do you want to know how to deal with your toddler’s tantrums without using time-outs and punishments?  Here is one simple trick to help with toddler temper tantrums.

I have been working a lot this week. I work part-time out of the house but it’s not spaced regularly throughout the month. And there was a special project that meant I had to put in long hours this week. I was out of the house for 10 hours a day, so basically most of Squish’s awake time.

Since she’s used to having me around a lot more, this did not go over well.

I got home a bit before her bedtime last night and did the unwinding routine with her. All seemed good. Then suddenly a switch got turned on and unleashed a loud, emotional toddler tantrum.

Distraction didn’t work. Singing her favorite songs didn’t work. Offering her favorite stuffed animal to cuddle didn’t do a thing. Even her beloved soother (try not to judge us too much, she only gets it rarely now!) didn’t stop the tantrum.

I felt stuck and the temper tantrum was not letting up. Everybody parents differently but I don’t like leaving her to deal with those big out of control feelings by herself.  We don’t do time-outs or put her in her room by herself to finish the tantrum alone.

Related parenting content:

How to deal when your toddler tantrums

So I took a deep breath and said to her “I think you missed mama today.”

The screaming decreased by a couple of decibels.

“I think you’re mad and sad because I haven’t been home very much.”

She was starting to listen a tiny bit now (while the temper tantrum was still happening).

“I can understand you feeling upset. I missed you too. I’m here now. I will stay with you. I’m not leaving you when you’re feeling this way”

At that she cuddled into me and cried. The tantrum had crested and was receding.

Related content:

One simple trick to help your toddler when they’re having a temper tantrum

When you are dealing with toddler tantrums and distraction and other techniques aren’t working, or even before using those other techniques, try empathy. Toddlers brains are developing so quickly. They don’t have the ability yet to think things through and express how they’re feeling. But as their parent we can try to help them by saying we understand.

I try to remind myself when we’re in the throes of a temper tantrum that she’s not trying to be difficult, she’s having a difficult time.

There are many things in a toddler’s life that could lead to toddler tantrums:

  • You just had a baby and your toddler is adjusting to the new addition and their new place in the family

  • A parent has been working longer hours

  • The toddler started daycare or preschool

And there are the simple everyday events such as:

  • You gave your toddler milk when they really wanted water

  • You gave your toddler milk and they wanted milk but now they changed their mind

  • They wanted to dress themselves but then couldn’t do it and got frustrated

Final thoughts on how to deal with temper tantrums

There is a lot in a child’s life that is out of their control. Instead of punishing or withdrawing from a temper tantrum, do the opposite.  Lean in.  Tell them you love them.  Tell them you are there and you will stay with them until they’re feeling better.  This isn’t enabling them or “encouraging bad behavior”.  They will learn to control their emotions with time as their brain develops, and with support.  During a tantrum is not the time for explaining or teaching or having a rational discussion.  They just need to feel like someone is there.

Quick note: If you as the parent are getting way too frustrated or even angry from their temper tantrum then by all means make sure they are in a safe space to flail and kick and remove yourself until you calm down.

If I had thought that my daughter’s temper tantrum was only about something trivial and left her in a time out until she calmed down, how would this have made her feel?  She was missing her mama, that was a likely underlying feeling.  A time-out would have exacerbated her feelings of me not being there.

There is no single magic bullet that will stop all toddler tantrums in their tracks.  I know this won’t work every single time.  But staying with them and supporting them through (this book on positive parenting has helped me out so much!) it will make them feel less alone with their big scary feelings.  And it just might shorten the length of their temper tantrum.

—–> Pin this post to save it for later or share it if you found it helpful!

How to deal with your toddlers tantrums without using time-outs and punishments | toddler tantrums | 2 year old tantrums | 3 year old tantrums

How do you deal with toddler tantrums?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Long road trips with toddlers can be fun! (yes really) - The Curious Frugal

Sunday 3rd of November 2019

[…] On a road trip with kids, definitely stop if you need to get gas or for washroom breaks for anyone. But wait to take your long break until your toddler needs it.  You will know when your toddler needs it! Snacks and toys and other distractions will stop working and they will get fussier or if you’re really lucky you could get a full-blown tantrum. […]

Toddler Temper Tantrums: The #1 thing you should NOT say during a tantrum - The Curious Frugal

Monday 19th of August 2019

[…] How to deal with toddler temper tantrums without time-outs or punishments […]

Savannah Smith

Wednesday 29th of May 2019

I love this idea!! I love trying to figure out what's bothering my toddler just by talking to him. It seems like it really does help him tell me what's bothering him. These toddlers are such a handful, but they're such a blessing!!

I wrote a similar post about Understanding tantrums at https://mylifemommy.com/2019/05/18/understand-toddler-tantrums/ So if you could please check it out and let me know what you think. Thank you!

TheCuriousFrugal

Wednesday 29th of May 2019

Glad you liked these ideas on how to deal with toddler tantrums! Toddlers can really test our patience, or we can use them as an opportunity to practice our patience. They're not easy, but I agree, they are awesome! :)

Parenting Guilt – How to get rid of it for good - The Curious Frugal

Monday 18th of March 2019

[…] How to deal with toddler tantrums […]

Age-appropriate chores for 3 year olds (nope it's not too early to start!) - The Curious Frugal

Monday 17th of December 2018

[…] How to deal with toddler tantrums without using timeouts or punishments […]

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.